My current Top 5

My current Top 5

6/27/2011

Number 70: Ethel Barrymore as Ma Mott in "None but the lonely Heart" (Best Supporting Actress Ranking)

In my initial ranking of the winners in this category, Ethel Barrymore made it up to position 53 but like Mary Astor, she, too, has gone down a few places now.

Considering that Ethel Barrymore is called one of the greatest American actresses, I find her work in movies very…limited. She basically uses the same acting style in every role she takes – a knowing smile, her head lowered to the front, a slightly sarcastic line-delivery. All this works and I have never seen a bad performance by this actress – but she doesn’t exactly blow me away either.

In None but the lonely Heart she played the strong, bitter but ultimately loving mother of good-for-nothing Cary Grant. None but the lonely Heart is an extremely dated motion picture – the kind of movie that probably was hailed as very realistic in the 40s but leaves a rather bad taste today. Cary Grant played his part with charm and ease but ultimately he was much better suited for the kind of roles he is mostly known for – elegant comedy. Ethel Barrymore is probably the best player in this tale and it’s not hard to see why the Academy honoured her – her controlled and grim performance fits the movie and dominates it at the same time. But, as I said, for me, it feels too dated and too limited to be truly effective.

We first meet Ma Mott when her son comes home again and you immediately realize that there is not much love between them. Ma Mott says to her son (after slapping him): “I don’t get more respect from you than from that father of yours” and then she tells him “Stay or go!” Later, we find out that Ma Mott is seriously ill and that there may not be much more time – but she is too proud to tell her son. But he does find out anyway and decides to stay with her and help her. Now we can see how the two of them start to like each other and begin getting along.

It’s a role that allows Ethel Barrymore to show everything that actors can dream of – anger, frustration, fear, love, happiness, desperation. But in combination with Ethel Barrymore’s acting style, it all lacks life, energy and almost every interesting aspect. But she shines whenever she lets the viewer see that underneath her grim face is actually love and she is also very impressive when she tries to hide her pain from her son – Ethel Barrymore makes Ma Mott an exhausted woman, who never had an easy life and who is always worried about the things around her. And so she ended up as this bitter, no-nonsense woman who doesn’t know what the future will bring.

Ethel Barrymore is not bad, definitely not. But it’s the kind of performance that you most likely feel ‘neutral’ about – not bad but not exactly great either and not a performance you would want to watch again.

1 comment:

Louis Morgan said...

As you said she is the best part of the film, and I really think, again, she did enough to be positioned higher than this.