My current Top 5

My current Top 5

3/26/2010

Best Actress 1978 - the resolution!

After having watched and reviewed all five nominated performances, it's time to pick the winner!


5. Jane Fonda in Coming Home

Jane’s performance never fights against the weakness of the script that reduces Sally to a boring love interest but rather even emphasizes it by also investing Sally with nothing else but a simple-mindedness that does nothing to make her the least bit interesting.



                     
Ellen Burstyn’s performance is charming and lovely, sometimes amusing, sometimes touching, but her acting stays mostly on the surface and she is never able to create a full-flesh human being out of her paper-thin character.




Even though her screen time is limited, Geraldine Page still dominates the whole movie with a convincing, shocking, frightening and sad portrayal of a woman who loses control and is not able to deal with the failure of her own marriage.



2. Jill Clayburgh in An Unmarried Woman

Jill Clayburgh is smart, funny, sexy, strong, weak and, most of all, very natural and always confident while she creates a very relaxed and self-assured character with a wonderful mix of strength and humor.

                


Ingrid Bergman gives a devastating performance as a woman who lives a live of pretending, who can associate with everyone but her own daughters and who finally has to look into her own past and her own soul to see who she really is.




4 comments:

Sage Slowdive said...

Yay!

Too bad she really didn't win...

Fritz said...

Yeah, or Jill Clayburgh or anyone else but Jane Fonda...it's impossible to find anyway today who actually agrees with her win.

joe burns said...

When I read your review of Clayburg, I thought she might be your pick, but I guess people love Ingrid! I could do this year, but I refuse to sit through Interiors again.

Fritz said...

It was VERY close between Ingrid and Jill!